GirlChat #362709
Re: ???
Posted by Hen-Wen on 2006-July-25 03:06:48 EDT, Tuesday
In reply to ??? posted by Infinity on 2006-July-24 19:41:35 EDT, Monday
Right, Infinity, exactement. No matter what you do, the kid is going to get them if he really wants them. And as much as you disparage psychology, there are thousands of experiments which demonstrate that punishment and coercion are not very effective at distinguishing behaviours. Forcing kids to do what you want them to do is not going to work.
So what's the solution? Well, despite your obtuseness, it is conceivable that even a mere child will have the wherewithal to realise that it's not worth the cash-flow problem or the indigestion that comes with an addiction to Cheetos. But even better, try treating the children like the cognitively capable human beings they are and giving them better options and advice.
To put it more simply:
Forbidding something = makes it more attractive.
Punishment = Temporarily supresses behaviour, ultimately only encourages the subject to hide his activities and resent the punisher.
vs.
Positive reinforcement + cognitive interaction = Lasting behavior change, lack of pathological relationship.
This post is archived, preventing any new replies.
Responses
- I think you're still not seeing my point. - Infinity on 2006-July-25 16:08:51 EDT, Tuesday - (1 / 0 / 1)
- Ok, Inf -- - Hen-Wen on 2006-July-25 20:57:28 EDT, Tuesday - (1 / 0 / 0)
- Re: ??? - turtle on 2006-July-25 05:00:54 EDT, Tuesday - (1 / 0 / 2)
- Thanks, I'm glad you understand. - Hen-Wen on 2006-July-25 14:34:41 EDT, Tuesday - (2 / 0 / 0)
- Re: ??? - Demosthenes on 2006-July-25 08:11:08 EDT, Tuesday - (2 / 0 / 0)