There is one point there which I like

-Someone who willingly breaks the law knows of the consequences and severe harm this can cause Abby. I don't do anything with Abby even if I believed it wouldn't harm her because of this. So if someone did happen to be doing anything with her I would be extremely upset because to me that shows he doesn't care about her.

Even considering the law as unfair, being willing to break it means being willing to take extraordinary risks greater than the usual risks in living. One of those risks is being murdered for no apparent reason. So, yes.